Given the current circumstances, our office staff will primarily be working remotely. We will have a reduced number of people on site from 9:00 am to 4:00 pm. Our staff will still be responding to emails and phone calls and continuing to do the necessary things to care for our clients. We ask that if you do not need to visit our office in person, you stay home and contact us via telephone or email. We are still here to serve and hope that everyone stays safe and healthy.

Serving Injured Clients & Their Families Throughout Arizona
Do You Have A Case?
Call us today for a free consultation
Harris powers* & cunningham
Catastrophic Injury And Wrongful Death Attorneys
Phoenix Injury Attorneys
Harris powers* & cunningham
Catastrophic Injury And Wrongful Death Attorneys
Medical
Malpractice

wrongful
Death

Personal
Injury

Car
Accidents

Truck
Accidents

Insurer’s bad-faith conduct spotlighted in malpractice lawsuit

And it is certainly notable — especially for victims who must routinely square off against individuals and institutions making all efforts to shield themselves from liability — that multiple defendants can be targeted in medical malpractice litigation. Doctors are often culpable in a fundamental sense, of course, but in many instances so are anesthesiologists, nurses, lab technicians or other medical professionals.

There is an additional party that is occasionally placed front and center in a medical malpractice lawsuit for conduct alleged to be wrongful and even wanton, namely, an insurance company.

A national news story spotlights the bad-faith behavior of one large malpractice insurer in a recently concluded malpractice trial in Chicago. That case featured the parents of a newborn who suffered from oxygen deprivation during birth and was born with a brain injury that subsequently proved to be fatal.

The insurer was not an original defendant in underlying litigation focused upon a team of obstetricians. That case resulted in a money judgment against those defendants.

Subsequently, though, the parents of the deceased child filed a bad-faith lawsuit against the insurer — ISMIE Mutual Insurance — for its failure to pursue settlement negotiations in good faith when it reasonably knew that a damage award against the obstetricians might exceed the limits of their malpractice coverage. Failure to do so put the doctors at risk.

Allegedly, ISMIE purposefully misled its clients both about the amount of coverage available to settle a claim and an offer made by the plaintiffs that was arguably in the physicians’ best interests.

It took a jury less than one hour in deliberations earlier this month with ISMIE being slapped with a $14.3 million judgment. Of that amount, $13 million was levied as punitive damages for the insurer’s bad-faith conduct.

And it is certainly notable — especially for victims who must routinely square off against individuals and institutions making all efforts to shield themselves from liability — that multiple defendants can be targeted in medical malpractice litigation. Doctors are often culpable in a fundamental sense, of course, but in many instances so are anesthesiologists, nurses, lab technicians or other medical professionals.

There is an additional party that is occasionally placed front and center in a medical malpractice lawsuit for conduct alleged to be wrongful and even wanton, namely, an insurance company.

A news story from the Chicago Tribune spotlighted the bad faith behavior of one large malpractice insurer in a recently concluded malpractice trial in Chicago. That case featured the parents of a newborn who suffered from oxygen deprivation during birth and was born with a brain injury that subsequently proved to be fatal.

The insurer was not an original defendant in underlying litigation focused upon a team of obstetricians. That case resulted in a money judgment against those defendants.

Subsequently, though, the parents of the deceased child filed a bad-faith lawsuit against the insurer — ISMIE Mutual Insurance — for its failure to pursue settlement negotiations in good faith when it reasonably knew that a damage award against the obstetricians might exceed the limits of their malpractice coverage. Failure to do so put the doctors at risk.

Allegedly, ISMIE purposefully misled its clients both about the amount of coverage available to settle a claim and an offer made by the plaintiffs that was arguably in the physicians’ best interests.

It took a jury less than one hour in deliberations earlier this month with ISMIE being slapped with a $14.3 million judgment. Of that amount, $13 million was levied as punitive damages for the insurer’s bad-faith conduct.

Archives

FindLaw Network

REAL RESULTS

$3,234,253
Wrongful death of young mother due to delay in diagnosis…
$9,750,000
Failure to diagnose and treat infant resulting in permanent injuries to infant.
$5,875,000
Wrongful death of young mother with 2 minor children due to multiple…
$5,000,000
Head-on collision with drunk driver resulting in brain injury…
$4,250,000
Permanent injuries to adult male in hospital after guidewire left…
$3,234,253
Wrongful death of young mother due to delay in diagnosis…
$9,750,000
Failure to diagnose and treat infant resulting in permanent injuries to infant.
"Ethical & Professional"
Thank you for your patience and understanding. I was impressed when we first met you, as I still am today, with how ethical and professional you are. I know we were very fortunate to have you representing us. I also want to thank your staff for all they have done. Please pass on our appreciation to anyone that had anything to do with our case. – LA
"Best Attorney Ever!"
I want to thank you for all your efforts on our behalf in settling our legal claim concerning my dad’s death. We’re grateful that we finally prevailed and are relieved to put it behind us now. But as gratifying as that has been, what remains with me the most is my deep gratitude for your compassionate..” – GG
"Your Reputation Got Us The Favorable Settlement Amount"
I never had any doubts that we were in the best legal hands. I’m convinced that your reputation got us the favorable settlement amount that we agreed on. – BA
"I Feel So Lucky To Have Found You"
I was dreading having to go through a legal battle along with trying to get well and feel well. I feel so lucky to have found you. I know you were doing your job, but I want you to know how much I appreciated your kindness and compassion. You really helped me through a difficult time in my life. – GP
"Incredible Work!"
It has been very hard for me to go through such a difficult time without my parents here. My dad would be so pleased and supportive of the incredible work you are doing for me. I know he is smiling and my mom is grateful. Thank you. – MK
"Ethical & Professional"
Thank you for your patience and understanding. I was impressed when we first met you, as I still am today, with how ethical and professional you are. I know we were very fortunate to have you representing us. I also want to thank your staff for all they have done. Please pass on our appreciation to anyone that had anything to do with our case. – LA
"Best Attorney Ever!"
I want to thank you for all your efforts on our behalf in settling our legal claim concerning my dad’s death. We’re grateful that we finally prevailed and are relieved to put it behind us now. But as gratifying as that has been, what remains with me the most is my deep gratitude for your compassionate..” – GG